Teaching / Teaching with AI / Examples
Logic and Ethics
Two courses I teach, with very different answers to the same five questions.
These are ideas to bring into the conversation with students. Each class can reach its own version of the contract from them. Download the blank template from the contract page.
| Logic | Ethics | |
|---|---|---|
| A. Educational purposeWhat kinds of intellectual work are students expected to learn and practice in this course? | Students need to understand exactly how a rule or system works and how definite its boundaries are. Then they need to learn to use it, including the less clear-cut challenges that involves, like deciding which rule to apply and when. | A non-arbitrary, non-algorithmic way of approaching moral problems. Students should be able to look at a problem without chalking it up to anyone’s opinion or calling it obvious, and see that it is hard but can still be attacked. |
| B. Appropriate assistanceHow can AI help students undertake that work, and when might it replace the very activity they’re supposed to develop? | Having AI solve the proofs replaces the skill the course exists to build. Using AI to see how a rule works, or why a step does or doesn’t fit a rule, could help. For the class: should questions about when a rule applies go to AI, to the instructor, or both? | AI can challenge ideas students already have. It shouldn’t generate the original ones. Asking “what’s a good reason to give the liver to this patient?” replaces the work. Asking AI to pick apart the argument you came up with is fine at this level. Getting past a conclusion to the premises behind it is often the hard part, and then challenging your own premises right after building the argument can feel close to impossible. AI can take the other side. |
| C. Evidence and responsibilityWhat must students demonstrate themselves? When is acknowledging AI assistance necessary to evaluate their work fairly? | Students must show they can decide when to use one rule and when to use another. Tell me if you use AI in a way we agreed not to. Beyond that, an invitation more than a demand: explain how AI helped you think through a problem. | Have those conversations with AI, and tell me about them. You don’t need to report every small thing. A word swap usually isn’t interesting, though sometimes it might be. |
| D. Reciprocal responsibilitiesWhat can students expect from the instructor regarding fair evaluation, privacy, educational judgment, and the use of AI? | I use AI to help build the applications we use in this course. Nothing you do in those apps is used by any AI system or recorded. They run entirely in your browser. | I use AI to come up with examples and prompts, and as a sounding board for thinking through a lecture. I don’t use it to replace my reading of your work. |
| E. Revision and uncertaintyWhat happens when someone encounters an unexpected use or a genuinely ambiguous case? | Bring unclear cases to me. For the class: what kinds of cases might that not settle? | Communicate. For the class: when might talking it through not be enough, and what then? |