Overview
This assignment asks you to demonstrate your philosophical understanding and reasoning by analyzing a situation using the concepts and tools from class. Your goal is to demonstrate that you have developed your understanding of issues, honed skills, and are able to do more than regurgitate ideas.
You will choose one of three cases and analyze it using the relevant concepts from class. This assignment is known as a scaffolded assignment, which means it has multiple parts which build upon each other. A major part of the process is two peer review sessions, one on your outline and another on a completed version of the paper. Be aware: if you only have a small sketch with a few lines for your outline, or only an incomplete draft before the peer review discussions, that will count against your grade.
Learning Outcomes
- Distinguish and critically evaluate the major schools of philosophy.
- Demonstrate an understanding of the methods of philosophical thinking.
- Apply philosophical theories to current issues.
- Demonstrate philosophical and/or logical thinking through writing and other forms of assessment.
For the key things to keep in mind while writing, refer to the Evaluation Rubric.
Go to
Cases
Your entire paper will be built around the case you choose. The concept requirements are specific to each case. See the note under your chosen case.
Case A: Personal Identity
Dana is a space explorer. Before her next mission, she is discovered to have also been a bank robber on the side. At the time this is discovered, there is no dispute about who Dana is or that she did the robbing.
Before she is arrested, Dana undergoes a transport procedure required for her mission. Over a very short period of time, Dana's body is scanned at the molecular level. As each molecule is scanned, a corresponding molecule is assembled at the destination, arranged to match Dana's complete physical and psychological structure. At the same time, Dana's original molecules are removed and stored. Dana's expressed wishes are that these original molecules are never touched again. But several days later, against her wishes, those original molecules are reassembled according to the same recorded structure.
For a brief interval during the process, no body exists that is Dana. After the procedure, three things exist: a functioning body at the destination composed of newly assembled material (with Dana's memories and sense of continuity), a functioning body reassembled days later from Dana's original material (also with Dana's memories and character), and the complete informational record used to assemble both. Both bodies are utterly devastated and unsure how to feel about their own identity.
Your question: Who should be held accountable for robbing banks? The focus is not about morality or practicality, but about identifying who is Dana. What is the thing, after the procedure, that is numerically identical to the person that was robbing banks before the procedure?
Cases
Your entire paper will be built around the case you choose. The concept requirements are specific to each case. See the note under your chosen case.
Case B: Free Will
Scenario A: Louise is deciding whether to call a coworker concerning a potential problem with the product they're putting to market. She considers calling, but also thinks it might be better to wait until the weekend. After reflecting, Louise decides not to call that night. It's potentially a significant issue, but she doesn't think it's worth interrupting everyone's weekend. Her colleagues later find out she had been worried but didn't call, and blame her for it.
Scenario B: Louise is deciding whether to call a coworker concerning a potential problem with the product they're putting to market. She considers calling, but also thinks it might be better to wait until the weekend. After reflecting, Louise decides not to call that night. It's potentially a significant issue, but she doesn't think it's worth interrupting everyone's weekend. Her colleagues later find out she had been worried but didn't call, and blame her for it.
Unknown to Louise while she is deliberating, there is a temporary service disruption affecting her phone's ability to contact her colleagues. It is impossible for Louise to make a successful call that evening or at any other time during the weekend. Even if she had tried to place the call, no connection could have been made.
Scenario C: Louise is deciding whether to call a coworker concerning a potential problem with the product they're putting to market. She considers calling, but also thinks it might be better to wait until the weekend. After reflecting, Louise decides not to call that night. It's potentially a significant issue, but she doesn't think it's worth interrupting everyone's weekend. Her colleagues later find out she had been worried but didn't call, and blame her for it.
Unknown to Louise while she is deliberating, there is a temporary service disruption affecting her phone's ability to contact her colleagues. It is impossible for Louise to make a successful call that evening or at any other time during the weekend. Even if she had tried to place the call, no connection could have been made.
It turns out that the disruption was caused by a hacker who knew about the flaw and deliberately blocked communication to prevent Louise from calling.
Scenario D: Louise is deciding whether to call a coworker concerning a potential problem with the product they're putting to market. She considers calling, but also thinks it might be better to wait until the weekend. After reflecting, Louise decides not to call that night. It's potentially a significant issue, but she doesn't think it's worth interrupting everyone's weekend. Her colleagues later find out she had been worried but didn't call, and blame her for it.
Unknown to Louise while she is deliberating, there is a temporary service disruption affecting her phone's ability to contact her colleagues. It is impossible for Louise to make a successful call that evening or at any other time during the weekend. Even if she had tried to place the call, no connection could have been made.
It turns out that the disruption was caused by a hacker who knew about the flaw and deliberately blocked communication to prevent Louise from calling.
The hacker happens to be part of a large organization intent on harming the company. They have spent the last 18 months conducting a secret scheme to make Louise feel tired on Fridays and unlikely to handle responsibilities. In particular, they order every rideshare in the city on Fridays so she has to walk. They are in control of numerous billboards on the way to work, and bombard her with advertisements of heavy meals that she likes but make her feel tired and irritable after. They send her online accounts numerous rage-bait headlines and incessantly create new accounts anytime she blocks them. When Louise decides not to call, she says it's because it's what she really wants to do right now (not deal with anything and just relax).
Your question: In each scenario, were Louise's colleagues right to blame her? That is, should they consider her decision a free action? More generally: what determines whether Louise acted freely, and how should the details of each scenario bear on that question?
Cases
Your entire paper will be built around the case you choose. The concept requirements are specific to each case. See the note under your chosen case.
Case C: Theory Evaluation
Earthquakes are notoriously difficult to predict. Scientists lack well-established methods for forecasting where and when they will occur, and it is an active area of research to come up with a reliable theory and methodology to do so.
On May 1st, Genly proposes a new theory and predicts, based on the available data, that an earthquake will occur in a particular location between September 10th and September 17th. A few months go by, and an earthquake occurs in that location on September 18th.
On November 1st (after the earthquake occurs), Estraven proposes a new theory, not a development or refinement of Genly's but a completely new approach. Their theory, given the same data available to Genly in May, predicts an earthquake would occur exactly on September 18th (which it did).
Your question: How should we evaluate which theory is better? What are the relevant epistemic features? What information here helps us make the decision and what else would be useful to know about the theories? Argue for which theory we should favor (if either) and explain what would strengthen our confidence in either going forward.
Part 0 — Take Notes
The assignment is broken into parts which build on each other. Be sure to check the due dates for each of the parts in your syllabus.
Before you start outlining, spend some time with the case. Use the questions below to get your initial reactions down and start chewing on the philosophical issues. You don't need polished answers. The point is just to start thinking. Get your ideas on the page so you can start organizing and analyzing them.
Introducing and clarifying the case
- How would you describe the situation in your own words? What's actually going on here?
- What is the specific philosophical question you need to answer?
- Why is this question hard? What makes the answer unclear? What's at stake for the people involved?
The relevant concepts
- What concepts, views, or frameworks from class are relevant to your case? See the concept requirement on your case page.
- How would you explain those concepts to someone who hasn't taken this course?
- How do those concepts connect to the specific question you identified?
Analyzing with those concepts
- What do the relevant concepts or views say about your case? What does each one point toward?
- Are there tensions, either between competing views or within the view you're defending? What pulls in different directions?
- What is the right way to navigate those tensions? Why that way and not another?
- Given all of that, what is the right answer to the question, and why?
Objections and responses
- What are some potential weaknesses in your argument? Where is it most vulnerable?
- Why might someone reject what you're saying? What's the strongest version of that objection?
- How would you respond, without simply repeating your original argument?
Part 1 — Outline
Plan the structure of your paper, including the key points that you will be making and how everything will be organized.
Your paper will have sections. Just like you group sentences into paragraphs, you'll group paragraphs into sections. Here is an example of how to section your paper:
- Introduction
- The Dilemma
- My Contribution (this is where your main argument goes)
- Possible Objections
- Responses to Objections
- Conclusion
In each section, bullet out all of the important thoughts you want to get across relating to that topic. Here is what the Dilemma section might look like for Case A (personal identity):
- The Dilemma
- The basic situation (the basic facts without philosophy terms)
- The key philosophical question: ___
- The view I am working with, and what it says identity consists in
- example that illustrates the view in a clean case
- What the view says about the first body after the procedure
- What the view says about the second body after the procedure
- Drive home the point (i.e. what is the problem you'll solve): the view seems to give the same answer about both, which creates a problem
Here is the same section for Case B (free will):
- The Dilemma
- The basic situation (the basic facts without philosophy terms)
- The key philosophical question: ___
- Why free will matters for responsibility and blame
- The view I am working with
- example that illustrates the view in a clear case
- Why the view gives an intuitive answer for Scenario A
- Why Scenario B is less comfortable
- Drive home the point (i.e. what is the problem you'll solve): it's not obvious what makes Scenario A and Scenario B different in a way that should matter to whether she was free
And here is the same section for Case C (theory evaluation):
- The Dilemma
- The basic situation (the basic facts without philosophy terms)
- The key philosophical question: ___
- What the relevant epistemic standards are and why they're the right ones for evaluating theories
- Standard #1: ___
- What it means
- How it applies to theory evaluation generally
- Standard #2: ___
- What it means
- How it applies to theory evaluation generally
- Standard #3: ___ (etc.)
- Standard #1: ___
- What Genly's theory has going for it in light of those standards
- What Estraven's theory has going for it in light of those standards
- Drive home the point (i.e. what is the problem you'll solve): each theory has at least some claim to being better, so the problem is which one we should choose
Each of these bullets deserves its own paragraph. (This is just an example. Your paper will have different paragraphs depending on the concepts you're considering and the point you're making.) You'll want to do this for each of your sections.
Think of the sections as buckets for categorizing your ideas. When you start to think of a potential problem with your approach, put that as a bullet in the Possible Objections bucket.
Briefly introduce the case, identify the specific philosophical question you will answer, and preview your argument. Don't just summarize. Give the reader a reason to keep reading.
Explain the scenario and identify what makes it philosophically puzzling. Part of doing this well is explaining the theoretical lens you're using — that's what makes the dilemma visible in the first place.
- Describe the scenario in your own words. Don't just copy the prompt
- Identify the specific philosophical question you need to answer
- Explain why this question is difficult: What makes the answer unclear? What is at stake?
- Define and explain the key concepts of your chosen view accurately and in enough detail for someone unfamiliar with the course
- Explain why these particular concepts are relevant: What do they help us understand about the puzzle?
- Show how these concepts connect to the question you identified
Apply the concepts of your chosen view to work through the question.
- What are the key considerations your view identifies in this case?
- Are there tensions, either between competing views or within the view you're defending? What pulls in different directions?
- What is the right way to navigate those tensions, given your view? Why that way and not another?
- Given your analysis, what is the right or best answer, and why?
- You may briefly acknowledge what the other view might say, but your analysis should be grounded in the one you chose
- What are the potential weaknesses in your argument? Where is it most vulnerable?
- What's the strongest version of an objection to your position?
- What would someone holding a competing view say against your argument? What is the strongest version of that attack?
- How would you respond to each objection, without simply repeating your original argument?
- Acknowledge what assumptions you are making and what remains uncertain or unresolved
Restate what you've established and why. Acknowledge remaining uncertainty without abandoning your argument.
Part 2 — Outline Peer Review
A professional writing process involves many iterations of revisions, feedback, revisions, feedback, and so on. When it comes down to it, the art of writing becomes the art of revising: incorporating and reconciling new ideas into the way you're trying to articulate things. It becomes an externalized form of thinking. We only get two iterations in this class (the two peer review discussions), so we will need to utilize them as much as possible to practice the skill of revising. Take the peer review discussions seriously. They can have long-lasting impacts on your skills as a writer.
What to do
You will be placed into groups of three within D2L. Go to the peer review discussion for this assignment and post your outline there. Read your group members' outlines and leave feedback for each of them. Be sure to stay up to date with the schedule in D2L.
Print off two copies of your outline and bring them to class on the designated peer review day (check your syllabus). You will exchange copies with a partner and review each other's work in class.
How to conduct the review
When reading your partner's outline, use these questions to guide your feedback. Be specific. Vague comments aren't useful.
- Is the overall structure clear? Does the sequence of sections make sense, or are things in a confusing order?
- Is the dilemma section doing enough work? Does it explain why the question is genuinely hard, or does it treat it as already settled?
- Is the theory or framework being applied actually connected to the case, or does it feel abstract and generic?
- Is there a real position being taken and defended, or is the paper just presenting multiple views without committing?
- Are the objections genuine, the strongest version of a challenge to the argument, or are they weak or strawman versions?
- What is missing? What would you want to see that isn't there?
What to do with the feedback
Be sure to take notes during the session. When reviewing the feedback you received, ask yourself:
- What worked well? What did the reviewers seem to like?
- What didn't work so well? Where could there be room for improvement and in what ways?
- What are some completely new ideas you and/or one of the reviewers thought up for your paper? What is something that your paper will include that wouldn't have been included without this discussion?
Consider your feedback and adjust your outline before you begin the full writing process. Change the sections, paragraphs, etc. so that you're building from the right blueprint. The outline does you no good if it's obsolete.
Part 3 — Paper
First: revise your outline
Before you start writing, go back to your outline and update it based on the feedback you received. The outline does you no good if it's obsolete. Change the sections, add or remove bullets, rearrange things so that you're building from the right blueprint. If you're unsure how your outline should look, refer back to the Part 1 instructions.
Then: turn your bullets into paragraphs
Each bullet in your outline should become its own paragraph. Work section by section. For each bullet, ask yourself: what does someone need to understand for this point to make sense? What am I assuming they already know? What would make this clearer?
A few things to keep in mind while writing:
- Define any terms before you use them
- Discuss others' views, even those you disagree with, generously
- Be as clear as possible about what your assumptions are, what your conclusion is, and how your assumptions are meant to justify that conclusion
Part 4 — Paper Peer Review
A professional writing process involves many iterations of revisions, feedback, revisions, feedback, and so on. When it comes down to it, the art of writing becomes the art of revising: incorporating and reconciling new ideas into the way you're trying to articulate things. It becomes an externalized form of thinking. We only get two iterations in this class, so we will need to utilize them as much as possible. Take the peer review discussions seriously. They can have long-lasting impacts on your skills as a writer.
What to do
You will be placed into new groups of three within D2L. Go to the peer review discussion for this assignment and post your completed paper there. Read your group members' papers and leave feedback for each of them. Be sure to stay up to date with the schedule in D2L.
Print off two copies of your paper and bring them to class on the designated peer review day (check your syllabus). You will exchange copies with a partner and review each other's work in class.
How to conduct the review
When reading your partner's paper, use these questions to guide your feedback. Be specific. Vague comments aren't useful.
- Is the case explained clearly and in the writer's own words, or does it feel like a paraphrase of the prompt?
- Is the philosophical question clearly identified, and does the paper explain why it's genuinely difficult?
- Are the relevant concepts explained accurately and in enough detail that someone unfamiliar with the course would understand them?
- Does the analysis actually apply the theory to the case, or does it just describe the theory in the abstract?
- Is a clear position taken and defended with argument, or is the paper just presenting views without committing?
- Are the objections genuine and well-stated? Does the response to them actually engage with the challenge, or just restate the original argument?
- What is the single most important thing the writer could do to make this paper stronger?
What to do with the feedback
Be sure to take notes during the session. When reviewing the feedback you received, ask yourself:
- What worked well? What did the reviewers seem to like?
- What didn't work so well? Where could there be room for improvement and in what ways?
- What are some completely new ideas you and/or one of the reviewers thought up for your paper? What is something that your paper will include that wouldn't have been included without this discussion?
Part 5 — Revision
Based on the feedback received from the peer review discussions, revise your paper so that it's better than before.
How to use your feedback
There is not much new information to give you here. The point is to utilize the feedback you received and continue to use the rubric and the tips in these instructions.
When reviewing the feedback you received, ask yourself the same questions from the peer review stages:
- What worked well? What did the reviewers seem to like?
- What didn't work so well? Where could there be room for improvement and in what ways?
- What are some completely new ideas you and/or one of the reviewers thought up for your paper? What is something that your paper will include that wouldn't have been included without this discussion?
Checking your work
Your grade comes down to the rubric. If you're ever feeling lost, you can always turn to the rubric to see if you're satisfying the necessary criteria. And of course, don't hesitate to reach out for help.
Evaluation Rubric
Your paper will be evaluated on the following criteria. When in doubt about whether your paper is on track, return here.
| Criterion | Highly Proficient | Proficient | Partially Proficient | Not Yet Proficient |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Accuracy
LO 1
LO 5
|
Defines the central concepts precisely, states the key facts of the case accurately, and identifies the main philosophical puzzle. Presents the chosen view in terms a knowledgeable proponent would recognize as fair, careful, and complete. | Defines the main concepts correctly and states the central facts of the case clearly. Presents the chosen view fairly, though it leaves out a key distinction, compresses an important point, or describes the stakes only briefly. | Names the relevant concepts and facts but defines some terms loosely, blurs an important distinction, or leaves out a key part of the case. Presents the view in a partly recognizable way, but the explanation flattens or misstates some of what is at stake. | Misdefines central concepts, confuses or omits major facts of the case, or misidentifies the main philosophical puzzle. Presents the view or the case in a distorted way that makes the later analysis unreliable. |
|
Application & Depth
LO 4
LO 2
|
Applies the view directly to the specific facts of the case, traces multiple tensions or complications, and develops a line of analysis that moves beyond summary into sustained philosophical work. Tests the view against the case's harder details. | Applies the view to the main facts of the case and traces at least one genuine tension or complication. Moves beyond summary in several places, though some parts stay general or leave the strongest pressure point underdeveloped. | Connects the view to the case in scattered or uneven ways but spends most of the paper summarizing, restating the prompt, or listing considerations without developing them. Mentions complications briefly but does not trace how they affect the conclusion. | Repeats the view in the abstract, restates the case without analysis, or makes forced connections that do not actually guide the discussion. Treats a philosophically difficult question as simple or already settled. |
|
Reasoning
LO 2
LO 5
|
States a clear conclusion, gives connected reasons for each major claim, and addresses a serious objection or limitation without abandoning the argument. Shows what has been established, what assumptions the argument uses, and where uncertainty remains. | States a clear conclusion and gives reasons for the main claims, with most inferential steps made explicit. Addresses an objection, assumption, or limitation in a relevant way, though one part still needs fuller support or more careful qualification. | States a conclusion and offers some reasons, but several important claims rest on assertion, quick leaps, or unexplained transitions. Mentions an objection or limitation but handles it briefly in a way that does not significantly test the argument. | Asserts conclusions without supporting reasons, relies on circular or question-begging claims, or leaves the main inferential steps unstated. Either ignores objections entirely or dissolves the argument by treating every position as equally unsupported. |
|
Writing & Organization
LO 5
|
Uses a clear introduction, purposeful body sections, focused paragraphs, and transitions that show how each part advances the argument. Uses precise sentences and clean grammar so the reader can follow the line of thought without stopping to decode the prose. | Uses a recognizable structure with an introduction, body, and conclusion, and most paragraphs stay focused on one task. Generally clear sentences and mostly clean grammar, though a few transitions, paragraph breaks, or sentence-level problems interrupt the flow. | Uses a loose or uneven structure in which paragraphs drift, transitions rely on generic signals, or sections do not build cleanly on one another. Repeated sentence-level problems that slow the reader down or make some claims harder to track. | Lacks a workable structure, groups unrelated points in the same paragraph, or omits transitions that would show how the discussion fits together. Persistent sentence-level errors or confusing phrasing that makes the argument difficult to follow. |