Theory Selection Suite

v4.1

Choosing between theories

Three exercises in weighing rival explanations against evidence. In each one, the evidence is harder to get and harder to read than in the last.

Creatures
Identify a hidden creature by asking about its features. Every candidate is in view and every answer is reliable, so the work is in choosing good questions.
Garden
Find the growing conditions that produce the tallest plant before time runs out. Here you produce the evidence yourself by setting up comparisons.
Outbreak
Work out what is making a town ill when the obvious evidence fits several explanations, then report how confident you are in each one.
Creatures
One creature on the board has been picked at random. Ask about its features, rule out the creatures that don't match, and name it.

No two creatures share the same combination of features, and every answer you get is true, so each question rules creatures out for certain.

There's no limit on questions, but fewer is better. A good question rules out a lot of creatures however it's answered.

Easy
12 creatures, 3 features
Ask for a feature's value
Gold: fewest possible
Medium
20 creatures, 4 features
Yes/no questions
Gold: 5 questions or fewer
Hard
24 creatures, 6 features
Yes/no questions
Gold: 5 questions or fewer
Students who enter the same seed get the same board.
Questions asked: 0
Remaining: — creatures

The hidden creature

Ask questions to learn its features.

All creatures. Click any to inspect.
Ask a question
Click a creature on the board to guess.
Make a guess
Questions asked
No questions asked yet.
Correct
Garden
You control the conditions in every plot of a garden. Find the combination that grows the tallest plant, and grow one to the target height before the days run out.

Drag across plots to select them, set their conditions, then run a day and see what grows. A plant grows faster the taller it already is, so finding the best conditions early matters.

Some conditions have one clearly best setting and others barely matter. On Medium and Hard, some settings work better in combination. Hover over a plot to see its history.

Easy
4×4 plots, 2 conditions
Target: height 30 in 6 days
Medium
8×8 plots, 3 conditions
Target: height 45 in 8 days
Hard
12×12 plots, 4 conditions
Target: height 60 in 10 days
Students who enter the same seed get the same garden.
Tallest plant: 0 of 30
6 days remaining
Day 1
Best height: —
Drag across plots to select them, set their conditions, then run a day.
Target reached
Target not reached
Outbreak
People in a small town are falling ill. Several explanations are on the table, and the first evidence you see will fit more than one of them. Work out which is right, then report how confident you are.

Each day, new cases show up on the town map and in the case chart. Watching costs nothing. Everything else costs investigation hours, and you have a fixed number of them.

Visiting a household tells you which well and food shop it uses and who works at the Mill. On Medium and Hard, other illnesses are going around too, and a lab test tells you whether a resident has the outbreak illness.

You can also close a well, a shop, or the Mill. If you close the source, new cases stop once people who were already infected have fallen ill.

By the deadline, you report to the town council by spreading 10 chips across the explanations to show how confident you are in each. Chips on the right answer raise your score and chips anywhere else lower it, so it pays to report your honest confidence.

Easy
4 explanations
22 households, 15 hours
One illness in town
Medium
5 explanations
24 households, 15 hours
Other illnesses, lab tests
Hard
7 explanations
26 households, 13 hours
Adds marsh air and contagion
Students who enter the same seed get the same town, and their outbreaks match until someone closes a site.
Day 1
Ill now: 0
Ever ill: 0
Hours: 0
Evidence
Illness rates among residents whose exposure you know. Anyone who has had symptoms counts as ill unless a lab test says they have something else. Click a row to see it on the map.
ExposureIll among exposedIll among not exposed
Compare with
New cases per day
Counted by the day symptoms began. Red lines mark closures. Tan bars are illnesses a lab test showed were something else.
Explanations
Spread 10 chips to show how confident you are in each. You can move them at any time.
Notebook

Settings

Navigation
Return to main menu
About
Theory Selection Suite v4.1